What should a home service agency check in a client's Google Business Profile?

Short answer: nine things — completeness, category, photos, reviews, review velocity, NAP consistency, local content, map visibility, and technical health. Google says local ranking rests on relevance, distance, and prominence, and that there is no way to request or pay for a better ranking. TradesAd Suite's Local SEO Audit runs those nine checks with fixed thresholds and scores them against nearby competitors, and this article walks through each one in plain English, including what good looks like and what to fix first.

First, what Google actually rewards

Before the checklist, the frame it sits in. Google's own page on improving your local ranking names three factors: relevance (how well the profile matches what someone is searching for), distance (how far the business is from the searcher), and prominence (how well-known the business is). Everything an agency can usefully do to a profile works through one of those three. Distance is mostly fixed — the address is the address. Relevance and prominence are where the work is: the category, services, and description drive relevance; reviews, photos, and the wider web presence drive prominence.

Google is equally blunt about what cannot be bought. The same page says: "There's no way to request or pay for a better local ranking on Google." Any agency selling a ranking shortcut is selling something Google says does not exist. The nine checks below are the honest version of the job: make the profile complete, accurate, and visibly active, then measure where it actually shows up on the map. Each check gives a verdict of CRITICAL, WARNING, or GOOD — or NEEDS DATA when the data is not available, instead of guessing — and the thresholds come from our Local SEO Auditor rule file (Local SEO Rules v2026-10-14.3), which scores the profile out of 100.

Check 1: Profile completeness

Is every field filled in — primary and secondary categories, phone, website, hours, address, service area, services list, attributes, a description of 250 characters or more, and opening date? Google's ranking page puts it plainly: businesses with complete and accurate information are more likely to show up, and a profile with wrong information might not show up for relevant searches at all.

Our rule scores completeness over 12 fields. Below 60% complete is CRITICAL; 85% is the bar for GOOD. One honest limit: four of those fields — special hours, service area, services list, and opening date — are not exposed by the public Google Places and DataForSEO APIs, so in a Real audit they are excluded from the score and reported as "cannot verify from outside — needs owner access," never counted as missing.

Fix first if this is weak: fill every field. It costs nothing and takes an afternoon.

Check 2: Primary category match

Does the primary category say exactly what the business is — "Plumber," "HVAC contractor," "Roofing contractor" — rather than something close but wrong? Google's guidelines for representing your business say to choose the fewest categories it takes to describe the overall core business, and that all locations of a business must share the one category that best represents it. A roofer filed under "General contractor" is competing in the wrong room; a plumber filed under "Plumbing supply store" is telling Google it sells parts, not services.

Fix first if this is weak: set the primary category to the exact trade, then add the right secondary categories — for a plumber, "Drainage service," "Pipe repair service," "Water heater installation service." Never add categories for work the business does not do.

Check 3: Photo volume and recency

How many photos does the profile have, and how recently was the newest one added? Google's ranking page lists adding photos and videos as one of the direct ways to improve a profile. Our rule treats fewer than 20 photos as CRITICAL, 50 as the bar for GOOD, and a newest photo older than 90 days as stale.

Photos are the cheapest prominence signal a contractor owns. A truck, a crew, a finished job — real work, recent, with the business name visible where it naturally appears. Stock photos of smiling families do not help; Google and customers both read them as filler. Fix: upload a batch of real job photos now, then add one or two a month as jobs complete, so the recency clock never runs out.

Check 4: Review count and rating

How many reviews, what rating, and what share of them has the business answered? There is no official number from Google, so here is our published threshold: 50 reviews is the floor — below that, a profile is thin next to established competitors, and the score also compares the count against nearby competitors rather than judging it in isolation. Rating below 4.0 stars is CRITICAL; 4.5 and above is GOOD. And the reply rate matters: answering fewer than half of reviews is a warning sign.

Google's review management page explains that replies are posted publicly as the business and are themselves reviewed for policy compliance. A reply is a public document: thank the reviewer by name, answer the point, and never argue with a bad review in public. Fix: answer every unanswered review this week, oldest first, then ask every satisfied customer for one — a short text after the job, with the review link, while the work is fresh.

Check 5: Review velocity and recency

Are new reviews still arriving, or did they stop six months ago? A profile with 120 reviews and nothing since March looks abandoned next to a competitor with 60 reviews and three this month. Our rule compares the recent review rate against competitors — below 25% of the competitor pace is CRITICAL, 75% is GOOD — and treats a newest review older than 60 days as stale.

This check separates a profile someone set up once from a profile someone runs. Fix: ask after every job, every time. One review a week beats ten once a year, because recency is a signal in itself.

Check 6: NAP consistency and citations

Does the business name, address, and phone number match everywhere it appears on the web — directories, review sites, the company website, social profiles? NAP stands for name, address, phone, and inconsistency is how a business ends up with two half-profiles that split its prominence between them. Our rule scores the match rate across sources: below 70% consistent is CRITICAL, 90% is the bar for GOOD.

Watch for the common causes: an old phone number still listed on a directory, a suite number written three different ways, the business name with "LLC" in one place and without it in another. Fix: pick one canonical version of the name, address, and phone, write it down, and correct every listing to match it exactly — including the website footer, which is the source most directories copy from.

Check 7: Local content and semantic relevance

Does the business website talk about the trade, in the towns it serves? A perfect profile still loses if the site it links to says nothing local. Our rule scores the site: page title 40 points, H1 20, service-area pages up to 30, local mentions 10. Below 40 is CRITICAL; 70 is GOOD. Without a website, this check reports NEEDS DATA rather than failing the profile for something it cannot see.

Fix: make sure the title tag and H1 name the trade and the town ("Plumber in Kennewick, WA"), and give each service area its own page rather than one page listing ten towns. One page per town, with real content about the work done there, beats a keyword list every time.

Check 8: Grid visibility — where the business actually ranks

This is the check that answers the only question the client really cares about: when someone nearby searches for the trade, does the business show up on the map? Our rule measures it on a 3-by-3 grid of points around the business — nine search locations, the center and the eight points around it — and scores each cell by the business's rank there: top 3 earns full points, top 10 earns 60, top 20 earns 25. Below 40 overall is CRITICAL; 70 is the bar for GOOD.

The grid matters because distance is a ranking factor: a business can rank first from its own street and be invisible two miles away. Fix: there is no shortcut — the grid improves when checks 1 through 7 improve. Weakness in one direction usually means a content gap (check 7) or a review gap (checks 4 and 5) in that part of town.

Check 9: Technical local SEO health

Five small things about the website the profile links to: it loads over HTTPS, it responds instead of erroring, it has a click-to-call phone link, it carries LocalBusiness schema, and the website address matches the one on the profile. Below 60% of those items passing is CRITICAL; 85% is GOOD. Like check 7, this one needs a website to judge.

None of these is hard. The schema item is the one most contractors miss: a small block of structured data on the homepage that tells Google, in machine-readable form, the business name, address, phone, and hours. Fix: hand the five items to whoever runs the website. They take an afternoon.

The name-field trap

One more thing, outside the nine: it can end a profile rather than weaken it. Google's representation guidelines require the name to match the business's real-world name as used on the storefront, website, and stationery, and say unnecessary information in the name "isn't permitted, and could result in the suspension of your Business Profile." Keywords, taglines, city names, and phone numbers stuffed into the name field are a suspension risk, not a ranking tactic. If a client's profile name reads "Best Plumber Kennewick 24/7," fix that before anything else — a suspended profile scores zero on all nine checks. Our Google Business Profile Guard watches for this kind of silent drift after the fix, and scores appeal readiness if a suspension does happen.

How to run the nine checks on a client

The full list:

Work through them in order, and fix them in order. Completeness and category cost nothing and unlock everything else; the grid is the scoreboard that tells you whether the rest worked. Our Local SEO Audit runs all nine against live Google data and scores the profile against nearby competitors — Starter includes 3 Real audits a month free, Pro can add it for $79 a month, Scale includes it. Simulated audits, clearly stamped as simulated, are free for everyone to try first.

Questions agencies ask about auditing a client's Business Profile

What should a home service agency check in a client's Google Business Profile?

Nine things: profile completeness, primary category match, photo volume and recency, review count and rating, review velocity, NAP consistency across the web, local content on the website, where the business ranks on the map around town, and technical health like HTTPS and LocalBusiness schema. Google says local ranking rests on relevance, distance, and prominence — and that there is no way to request or pay for a better ranking.

How many reviews does a contractor need on Google?

There is no official number, but our audit treats 50 reviews as the floor: below that, a profile is thin next to established competitors. Rating matters as much as count — below 4.0 stars is critical, 4.5 and above is good — and so does the reply rate: answering fewer than half of reviews is a warning sign.

Does the business name on Google affect ranking?

It affects whether the profile survives. Google's guidelines require the name to match the business's real-world name as used on signage, stationery, and branding, and say that adding unnecessary information — keywords, taglines, locations — is not permitted and could result in suspension. Keywords stuffed into the name are a suspension risk, not a ranking tactic.

Can an agency audit a client's Google Business Profile without owner access?

Mostly yes. Profile fields, photos, reviews, citations, and map rankings are all visible from outside. Four things cannot be verified from public data — special hours, service area, services list, and opening date — and an honest audit says so instead of counting them as missing. Those need the owner to confirm.

What is the fastest fix on a weak Google Business Profile?

Completeness and category. Fill every field Google offers, fix the primary category to the exact trade, and add the right secondary categories. It costs nothing, takes an afternoon, and it is the foundation every other check builds on.

Audit the profile before you pitch the fix

Free to try. Nine published checks, fixed thresholds, scored against nearby competitors — same listing in, same report out.

Run a Local SEO audit

Keep the profile guarded after the fix →